A friend recently survived a harsh writing critique. It got me thinking about the power some critiques have to transform a productive writer into a drooling pool of goo. Writers, like actors, tend to put so much of themselves into their work, any perceived negative word can maim and sometimes even kill writing careers. This makes me sad, because there are many really good writers that either give up or become so self critical they can no longer function. Because of it, there are entire worlds we will never get to explore. Heroes and villains that we'll never get to love or loathe. Laughter never laughed and tears never shed. How awful for the rest of us.
I don't have a problem with negative or highly charged feedback. I haven't for a very long time. I did when I was very little, but I learned early on to ignore the negativity and hear the "intent" behind it.
One particular stepping stone in the thickening of my "critique armour" comes to mind.
I was privileged to have one of the best high school basketball coaches in womens sports (IMHO). I continue to benefit from having know this man. Newt was a tough coach. About as hard as they come. He made many of the girls well up and/or angry with his harsh criticism, including me. We had two choices.
Choice #1: "See" his passion for what it was (a genuine love for the game and desire to see a small-town group of girls achieve their potential and outperform teams from much larger schools) and "hear" what he was saying -- so we could learn from it and improve.
Choice #2: Whither and shrivel up until we died a horrible and painful death.
I consider myself lucky. I learned. And the rewards I got for learning will forever hold a place of honor in my heart. Thank you, Newt!
Hard critiques can be tough to take. With the hope of saving entire worlds and universes from crumbling, I encourage writers to try to "ignore the harsh and focus on the intent." It's not always easy, I know. Pay attention to the actual words, not the passion with which they are delivered. Bear in mind, some critics might simply be in a cranky mood when they are writing (or delivering) a critique. And some critics genuinely believe they are helping you become a better writer (a.k.a., successful) by providing such heavy-handed feedback.
A key lesson I've learned? Surviving a harsh critique is 95% perception of what's lurking behind the curtain of that harsh critique. Choosing to believe someone is dragging you over hot coals because they love and care about you and WANT you to be successful makes for a less bitter pill to swallow (even if it really isn't true). It's similar to getting up to speak publicly and picturing the audience in their underwear or riding rubber duckies with clown noses on. Same concept.
Choose.
Ignore the harsh.
Hear the words and intent.
Also... and I CAN'T emphasize this enough. YOU control your work. YOU control which feedback you want to take and which you decide to ignore and discard. YOU control your growth and progress in the writing craft.
My dear friend, Debbie Mumford, reminded me that if you receive several similar comments, you should probably pay attention, but if you get one from a lone voice from somewhere beyond the right field fence, it's your choice whether you want to listen and change your work based on that feedback. She goes on to say, "watch for *who* is critiquing. A SFF-oriented person will often not care for the voice of a romance writer, where your romance reader will be delighted by it." Great points!!
As I told my friend, your voice is unique. You will never please everyone. Never. You could be the best writer in history and you will still not please everyone. Someone will always be right there, eager to tell you what you should have done differently to make it perfect.
So, WRITE on, everybuggy! I want to go adventuring in your unique worlds and universes. I want to dance with your heroes and thwart your villains. Don't let a harsh critique keep you from becoming the writer you were born to be!



























